Chapters 5-26 Thoughts/Questions

Key

  • I wrote down my broad thoughts every two chapters in normal font
  • I highlighted instances I might use in my lesson plan by italicizing them
  • All of my questions are at the end under a separate header

Chapters 5-6

  • I thought it was interesting that Bao-yu visits the same land Zhen Shi-yin visited and in fact the same land he once lived in
  • The songs appear to be about the decline of the Jia family and the love triangle
  • The Jia’s demonstrate generosity while still showing off their family heritage

Chapters 7-8

  • Dai-yu feels like she is given leftovers and is also leftover in Bao-yu’s eyes because he chooses Bao-chai over her
  • Ying tian, the kidnapped girl, is now a servant in the Jia household

Chapters 9-10

  • There is an obvious divide of wealth and power even among students at the private school
  • Family ties and standing are very important which is why Jia Qiang has a servant deal with the bullies
  • Again, Bao-yu only asks for an apology for his friend who is a family member and doesn’t ask for anything for the one who isn’t

Chapters 11-12

  • Lust eventually leads to Jia Rui becoming ill and dying
  • If he had been able to obey the Taoist, he would have been fine, but he looks into the forbidden side and even at death can’t part with his lust

Chapters 13-14

  • Xi-feng is put in charge of another two houses and manages them with ease
  • Dai-yu’s tears for a lifetime of repayment continue with her father’s death

Chapters 15-16

  • Bao-yu’s father thinks that Bao-yu will never be more than a boy who plays with girls’ toys
  • Greed appears to corrupt Xi-feng as she undertakes matters that she gets compensation for but hides from the Jia family
  • Patience goes to great lengths to cover up Xi-feng’s actions and shows true loyalty

Chapters 17-18

  • Even more so than the funeral no expense is spared for Yuan-chun’s visit home – the funeral shows what people are willing to give up for a good ruler
  • Bao-yu is oft put down by his father when they are naming things but the names, he chooses are often still the best ones and accepted by the whole party
  • Chapter 18 shows the character contradiction of Bao-chi and Dai-yu – one is cheerful and the other sad which is reflected in their poetry

Chapters 19-20

  • Another female relationship of Bao-yu’s is explored which is with Aroma
  • Bao-yu appears to think of his servants as friends which is shown by how he helps with grooming and nursing them back to health
  • Xian-yun only adds to Dai-yu’s belief that Bao-yu is closer to Bao-chai, more loved, and more beautiful

Chapters 21-22

  • Bao-yu sleeps around which seems to cause his girl problems because every girl seemingly wants him
  • Although he seems to show growth when he relates the girls to the real world
  • The conflict between Xi-feng, Patience, and Jia Lian shows another master-servant relationship
  • The sign of the riddles seems to foretell short/ill-fated lives for the family

Chapters 23-24

  • Bao-yu’s father seems to realize he isn’t going to get another son and changes his attitude towards him in this section
  • The girls and Bao-yu move to the garden per Yuan-chun’s request to hopefully get Bao-yu to focus more on his studies
  • The actresses use flowes in their stores which seem to unconsciously remind Dai-yu of her life in the Land of Illusion

Chapters 25-26

  • The jade heals the two of “demons”
  • Dai-yu cries more tears to cover her debt

Questions

  • How does Bao-chai’s locket have almost the same inscription as Bao-yu’s jade?
  • The part on Jia Rui’s lust seems contrarty to the rest of the novel because Bao-yu can have his way but others can’t?
  • In a different source I read something about their being a small-pox god that they try to atone to when Bao-yu gets sick, is this accurate?
  • Again, another note I read on the book is that when kids are sick the parents must abstain from sex specifically in relation to Jia Liang and his desire not to?
  • Why does the book on love and talking about marriage make Dai-yu upset? It seems that if she were just to engage then Bao-yu would focus on her and not Bao-chai.
  • Is the monk and Taoist that keep reappearing throughout the work the same one?

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started